"Building on the strengths of the first issue, this book displays admirably the reasons why it is going to become a classic series -- undoubtedly one of the best released this year."
— Paul Skevington
, Sci-Fi Crowsnest
"As short as the story (Behemoth & Leviathan) was, it was well planned, executed, and masterfully done. A stunning piece worthy of the industry's top awards."
— Todd Callender
, Static Multimedia
"A clever setup that allows commentary on contemporary politics, bigotry and other topical matters. 'Elephantmen' deserves a look, if only to show us what, someday, could be."
— Ed Hall
, Atlanta Journal-Constitution
"The comic centralizes itself around a sensitive theme -- this time, religion -- and once again, the theme is not handled heavy-handedly at all. (5/5 bullets)"
— Robert Ring
, Silver Bullet Comics
"I have no frame of reference of the original comics, but these two -- are awesome."
— Nick
, Variant Edition podcast
"I was excited to find a comic that wasn't DC or Marvel that I could really get excited about. (Grade A)"
— Joel Tremblett
, Paperback Reader
"An interesting character study that reminds you that humans don't always have dominion over all creatures."
— Fletch Adams
, Broken Frontier
"The artwork as always is beautiful and lends a lot to the story."
— Gabriel Diaz
, comiXtreme
"The imagination and meticulous development of this sci-fi society is awe-inspiring and entertaining, but the real strength of this new series is its strong foundation in characterization."
— Don MacPherson
, The Fourth Rail
"For all its futurist grime and genetic atrocities, this is an unfailingly pleasant book, the sort of thing you can quite easily pick up every month to stare into the viewfinder at Hip Flask's silly/violent/hopeless/parodic world."
— Jog
, Jog the Blog
"Elephantmen is a must-read series. If the complex plot and story don't draw you in, the art definitely will. (4/5)"
— Dana Tillusz
, ComicReaders.com
"The art is awesome, and the world seems fully developed and lived in."
— Jimbo887
, Newsarama forums
"I'm pleased to say it rocked my nether regions ever so gently."
— Dru
, Powet.tv
"A surprisingly good read...especially the Howard Stern-ish story!"
— The Fan Man
, The Comic Fanatic
"The art's nice, the fight is brutal, and seeing these beings behave like the animals they're based on is unnerving."
— Mikester
, Progressive Ruin
"A little disturbing as well as amusing... 'Shock Croc' is shocking. (5/5 stars)"
— Richard Vasseur
, Jazma Online
