"This is science fiction that doesn't take itself too seriously and is all the more enjoyable for reveling in its pulp origins. (A-)"
— Ian Woolstencroft
, BlogCritics
"The world of Hip Flask is one that almost anyone could enjoy. Seriously. Even my mother enjoyed the one I left in her bathroom one day. (5/5 bullets)"
— Adam Sward
, Silver Bullet Comics
"The Elephantmen is not just sci-fi noir at its best; it's an entertaining read that displays some of the best storytelling in the industry today...period. (10/10)"
— Kevin Agot
, The Comics Review
"The artwork for both pieces is incredible. Issue after issue this series continues to impress. (4/5)"
— Gabriel Diaz
, ComiXtreme
"With only a few scenes, Starkings and his artistic compatriots dredge up far more interesting ideas than most mainstream comic books do. And, of course, a big elephant-man goes apeshit. What more do you need?"
— Greg Burgas
, Comics Should Be Good
"The two (stories) provide a solid balance of entertainment... and Moritat delivers a spectacular job."
— Marc Mason
, Comics Waiting Room
"A strong and enjoyable third issue."
— Scott Cederlund
, Pop Syndicate
"Filled with wonderful art that will take you back to when comics where great. (5/5)"
— Richard Vasseur
, Jazma Online
"Boy can (Moritat) draw the cuties. If you only buy one issue of ELEPHANTMEN, this would be it for the Bolland cover and (sigh) Miki. "
— Dave Sim
, Dave Sim's blogandmail
