"This is pure quality from start to finish. Guest artist Rob Steen fills in for regular series artist Moritat and does so tremendously. Fans of EC and Elephantmen readers alike should definitely not miss this well-crafted book."
— Ryan the Iowan
, Newsarama Weekly Power Rankings
"A creepy one-off tale that brings to mind EC's shockers from back in the Fifties."
— Matt C
, Paradox Comics
"A disturbing and horrifying tale that, like the rest of the series, keeps the science fiction aspect while commenting on current events."
— Greg Burgas
, Comics Should Be Good