"Must Read. Elephantmen is my favorite comic and this issue is another great example of why."
— Ryan the Iowan
, Weekly Crisis Power Review Rankings
"I'm finding myself unraveling one strand of the mystery only to discover two more await me. I simply can't wait for the next issue."
— Brandon Borzelli
, Geek Goggle Reviews
"Axel Medellin captures the dark and dirty Ladronn/Moritat look...and it can only be hoped that future issues look as nice as this one does."
, Weekly Comic Book Review
"Elephantmen continues to be one of the best series out there, and I always look forward to where Starkings is going with it."
— Greg Burgas
, Comics Should Be Good!